The hairstylist was one of many Bachelor Nation all-stars who headed to Mexico for the debut season of Bachelor in Paradise. In Tulum, she joined Robert Graham and Chris Bukowski for dates, however it was Zack Kalter who actually caught her eye.
Regardless of these sparks, Clare left Paradise after enduring ambivalence from Zack and slut-shaming from costar AshLee Frazier. (“She had intercourse within the ocean,” AshLee had advised Zack. “That speaks quite a bit to her character.”)